It should be all done and dusted, shouldn’t it? With this Manchester United side, however, there is a nagging feeling that anything could happen on Thursday evening, ahead of their Europa League semi-final, second-leg clash with Athletic Bilbao.

Following last week’s remarkable 3-0 win away from home at San Mames, United return to Old Trafford with what appears to be an unassailable lead, having seemingly already placed one foot in the Bilbao showpiece later this month.

And yet, having notably shipped four against Lyon on home soil last month – with two of those goals coming against ten men – there remains a sense of anxiety regarding Ruben Amorim’s side. Will they shoot themselves in the foot at such a crucial point in the season?

Having almost thrown in the towel on the Premier League front, following a 16th top-flight defeat of the campaign away to Brentford at the weekend, the Red Devils simply can’t afford to end 2024/25 empty-handed.

Booking a place in the Europa League final is of paramount importance – Amorim must get his starting lineup correct…

Man Utd team news vs Bilbao

There is an element of two steps forward, one step back, with regard to United’s injury woes, having gradually begun to near full strength in recent weeks, only to subsequently suffer a handful of notable setbacks.

Chalkboard

Football FanCast’s Chalkboard series presents a tactical discussion from around the global game.

Indeed, the Premier League strugglers have been able to welcome back the likes of Mason Mount, Kobbie Mainoo, Luke Shaw and Amad Diallo of late, albeit while having lost the typically reliable, Diogo Dalot, for what looks to be the rest of the campaign.

That blow has been followed by concerns surrounding summer signing, Matthijs de Ligt, with the Dutchman having been forced off against the Bees on Sunday afternoon, after only making his return as a substitute against Bilbao last week.

Thankfully, Amorim revealed that the former Bayern Munich man’s injury is “not a big issue”, although the 25-year-old won’t be involved against Ernesto Valverde’s side this evening, thus leaving Amorim relatively short on depth considering that Lisandro Martinez remains a long-term absentee, while January arrival Ayden Heaven is also currently out of action.

With it looking unlikely that the former Sporting CP boss would unleash 20-year-old academy star, Tyler Fredricson, for a game of such huge importance, there is a selection dilemma to be solved for that final centre-back berth, alongside Harry Maguire and Leny Yoro.

Equally, the absence of Dalot has also left Amorim with something to ponder at wing-back…

How Man Utd’s defence should look against Bilbao

With Yoro and Maguire almost nailed on to start, fitness permitting, the final centre-back berth will likely be fought out by Victor Lindelof and Shaw – two options that both present something of a risk.

In the case of Lindelof, the 30-year-old Swede looked shaky in last week’s meeting in the Basque Country, despite producing a vital goalline clearance, while as for Shaw, the long-serving Englishman has endured a torrid return to action in recent weeks.

Introduced off the bench against Lyon, the 29-year-old notably bundled into Dalot for the visitors’ third goal, before subsequently giving away a penalty in extra-time, prior to being bailed out by United’s grandstand finish.

While he did play the full 90 minutes in the 1-1 draw with Bournemouth, Shaw was then hooked at the break against Thomas Frank’s men last time out, having scored an own goal amid a dismal 2/10 display as skipper.

Deploying the left-footer at centre-back would then be of real concern, as it would if he were to line up at left wing-back. That berth appears to be up for grabs, with teenager Harry Amass putting in his ‘weakest performance by a distance’ at the weekend, as per Manchester Evening News journalist, Samuel Luckhurst.

The obvious pick would be to select Patrick Dorgu on that side, with Noussair Mazraoui on the opposite flank, although the young Dane has struggled of late, with Luckhurst remarking that he ‘defended dozily’ for Kevin Schade’s header against the Bees.

While that 45-minute outing did see Dorgu line up on the right, even in his usual left-wing back berth he has toiled in recent games, with the trip to Bilbao seeing him lose possession on 12 occasions, as per Sofascore.

There could then be the option of deploying the aforementioned Amad in a new role on the left, with the Ivorian having stepped up his return with a stunning strike in stoppage time on Sunday.

Largely deployed as a number ten or at right-wing back, the natural left-footer could represent a wildcard replacement for Dorgu on the left flank instead, with Mazraoui retained as a more orthodox option on the right.

While it may seem a risk to make such a change in a game of huge magnitude, the 22-year-old “wizard” – as hailed by journalist James Copley – has the energy and exuberance to pose a real threat down that flank, thus forcing the lively Inaki Williams to track back more frequently.

Among those in his position in the Europa League this season, Amad notably ranks in the top 3% for progressive carries per 90, as per FBref, thus illustrating his ability to carry the ball forward from deep in a wing-back role.

Equally, his creditable work ethic also ensures that he represents a real asset defensively too, as showcased by the fact that he ranks in the top 19% for tackles made per 90.

Having seen Amass and Dorgu struggle of late, with the experienced Shaw also looking out of sorts at left centre-back or wing-back, Amorim should certainly consider making such a change.

This is yet another vital game in United’s wretched season, and Amad simply has to start, one way or another.

Related

He’d be amazing with Cunha & Amad: Man Utd in talks to sign elite striker

Manchester United could be allowed to land a new talisman who could supercharge their overhaul this summer.